Bill Conlin from the Philadelphia Daily News
I used to like Bill Conlin from the Philadelphia Daily News. I thought he wrote interesting stuff. Then this happened:
First he writes this ridiculous East Coast-centric rant:
Baseball Keeps Playing Past the Midnight Hour
Here is our email exchange:
Me:
Being currently situated in the Eastern Time Zone, I get your point. But what, exactly, is your proposed solution? Start the games at 8 ET, when it’s 6pm in Colorado and only 5pm in Arizona? Are television viewers really more important than ticket holders/fans in the states where the teams are from?
Him:
In the 37 postseasons I covered until just a few years ago, I covered many 5 o’clock starts in the Pacific time zone. Only ones bitching were TV viewers. They aren’t doing East Coast fans any favors, either with first pitches at 8:37 for games running well over four hours. These will be all-time low ratings this season for a Division Series and LCS. The TV money drives the engine, agreed? Since when did TV worry about inconveniencing the live gate?
Me:
Good point. Clearly the TV viewers are a huge issue, but that doesn’t solve the problem or change the nature of the issue. 5pm is really hard for people to get settled in in front of the game by (note the standard 7 or 7:05 start time throughout the year for most home games). So now we’re weighing the TV viewers in the home states vs. TV viewers on the East Coast. Why should we inconvenience the Western viewers? I think this gets to your “baseball alienating its fans” point. Would you be more comfortable with baseball culling east coast viewers and alienating local viewers? Or is there a compromise time that you think would suit all people?
Isn’t this only an issue because the NLCS was two west coast teams? If it was Phillies/Mets they would have all been 7pm (roughly) starts…It seems to me that baseball is doing the right thing for the fans of the teams involved.
Him:
Put them on against each other and let fan loyalties dictate. Also, I can flip between two or more games at once and hardly miss a pitch. With my Comcast DVR box, I can watch one live and record the other. It’s no longer an analog world.
Me:
Now you’re just begging the question. WHEN do you put them on against each other? 7pm ET? 7pm PT? To put them on against each other you have to sacrifice the convenience of either the west coast or east coast fan base. How do you do that without alienating fans?
Besides, if you’re comfortable watching one and recording the other, what is the issue in the first place? Record the late game and watch it in the morning. I suspect that’s not a real solution either…It seems you’re upset with geography, not MLB.
Him:
Don’t play academic mind games with me, pal. . .Even if you were a kid in Denver last night, your game ended after midnight. . .
Me:
Academic mind games? You’re continually refusing to answer the question and change the subject. What time would you simultaneously start both the NLCS and ALCS? Who would you alienate?
And for the record, an 8:18pm start to a 3:17 game means it ended at 11:35pm in Denver.
Him:
I am about to alienate you by putting you on block. This is not a chat room.
Me:
Glad to see you’ve carefully thought this through. Initially, I was honestly asking what you thought the solution would be. But clearly, you haven’t thought about it at all. Instead, you just went off on a rant against MLB, when really you’re just upset because some games happen to take place in a timezone you don’t live in. Then when I ask you about it, you resort to ad hominem attacks and withdraw from the conversation. That’s a heck of a way to stand behind your story. Good work. I hope blocking me from your email account makes you feel better.